I didn’t truly become a Jimmy Eat World fan until after Futures, but that album was so brilliantly written from start to finish, I had to go back and give everything else a shot. That developed into a full-blown rediscovery over a two year period, and it’s fair to say I’ve been looking forward to this album since I was aware they were capable of making good music.
The delightful news is that it doesn’t disappoint. It’s not quite as introspective as Bleed American or as deliberate as Futures, but it’s equally mature. The result is an album with only a couple clear standouts, followed closely by a string of super-solid songs with precisely the potential of growing on you over time. Immediate favorites are Always Be and Electable (Give It Up), but it’s an injustice to the rest if you think for a second they don’t each have something unique and intricate to offer.
My only complaint is the usual amalgamation of separating tracks for release in various territories. Another of the album’s best hits Be Sensible was omitted from the US retail, appearing instead on the UK release. There’s a handful of other tracks also available on iTunes and various preorder sites.
But as a whole, this release accomplishes the Jimmy Eat World sound in fine form, with all the potential of becoming a favorite over time. I just hope it doesn’t take three more years for the next round of new material.
8/10, with the potential to reach 9.